Is Retail Arbitrage Legal? Navigating the Business Model

Is retail arbitrage legal? Generally, yes, but there is also nuance you cannot ignore.

Is Retail Arbitrage Legal?

Is retail arbitrage legal? This query has perplexed numerous entrepreneurs, online merchants, and those hoping to start their first side hustle. This comprehensive blog post will delve into retail arbitrage, exploring its legality and providing valuable insights for those considering this business model.

We will begin by examining the basics of retail arbitrage and discussing its pros and cons. Next, we’ll navigate Amazon’s rules and regulations to ensure your venture remains compliant with its policies while avoiding common pitfalls that can lead to account suspension.

We’ll also explore alternatives such as private labeling and cover what you need to consider when building your brand on Amazon. We’ll also review the First Sale Doctrine concerning unauthorized sellers’ risks and respecting intellectual property rights within retail arbitrage.

Is Retail Arbitrage Legal? Is Online Arbitrage Legal?

Retail arbitrage (and its Internet-based counterpart, online arbitrage) is a popular business model for many small business owners looking to grow or start a side hustle. It involves buying products from local retailers and reselling them at a higher price in another marketplace. However, many people wonder if retail arbitrage is legal. The answer is yes. It is legal as long as it is done within the bounds of the law.

Rules and Regulations for Retail Arbitrage Sellers

While reselling products by buying low at retail and selling high, again at retail, it’s essential for sellers engaged in this business model to follow the rules and regulations carefully. Here are some tips to avoid suspension:

  • Listing restricted products: Ensure that your items are not part of Amazon’s list of restricted products.
  • Accurate product descriptions: Always provide accurate information about your retail arbitrage products, including brand names, sizes, colors, etc., as misleading listings can lead to account suspensions.
  • Excellent customer service: Respond promptly and professionally to customer inquiries and complaints. Negative feedback may affect your seller rating and risk suspension.

Managing Your Retail Arbitrage Business

Managing your business effectively is crucial to succeeding with retail arbitrage on Amazon. Here are some tips:

  • Use the Amazon Seller App: This app helps track inventory levels, monitor sales performance data (including potential profit margins), and set competitive pricing strategies based on market trends.
  • Keep an eye out for clearance sales: Local retail stores often have clearance sales, which can be an excellent opportunity to buy products at a lower price and potentially sell them for a higher price on Amazon.
  • Focus on high-demand products: Look for products in high demand on Amazon with a good profit margin. This will help keep your inventory flowing and your business profitable.

By following these tips and staying within the bounds of the law, retail arbitrage can be a profitable business model for Amazon sellers.

Retail Arbitrage on Amazon can be a lucrative way to make money online, yet it is imperative to comprehend the dangers and recognize typical errors that could bring about suspension. However, with proper research and tools such as Jungle Scout, you can increase your chances of success in sourcing profitable products for retail arbitrage.

Further Reading

We put together a guide on our favorite online arbitrage tools to help you grow your Amazon business from a side hustle to a profitable operation.

Limitations of Retail Arbitrage Compared to Private Labeling

Compared to private labeling, retail arbitrage is limited in terms of control over pricing, branding opportunities and profit margins. With retail arbitrage, you’re often at the mercy of fluctuating prices and availability in local retail stores. Private labeling provides more command over pricing, branding prospects, and gains than retail arbitrage.

Benefits of Private Labeling over Retail Arbitrage

  • Control: By creating your own brand through private labeling, you have complete control over the quality and presentation of your products.
  • Pricing: Unlike retail arbitrage, where you must compete on price with traditional retailers or other Amazon sellers offering similar products online, selling under a private label brand name allows you to charge higher fees due to the perceived value added by unique branding elements exclusively with your company.
  • Growth potential: Building a successful private label business can lead to long-term growth instead of short-term gains from sporadic clearance sales during retail arbitrage ventures.

Registering with the Brand Registry Program

Consider registering for their Brand Registry program to protect your intellectual property rights while selling on Amazon under a private label model. This will give you access to exclusive marketing tools designed specifically for registered brands and help prevent unauthorized reselling activities involving counterfeit goods bearing identical logos or packaging designs without proper authorization from original manufacturers- something often seen among retail arbitrage sellers.

In conclusion, retail arbitrage has limitations compared to private labeling and should be considered carefully before deciding. FBA offers numerous benefits for expanding its e-commerce presence and overseeing inventory.

Need more of that sweet Amazon knowledge?

All of our guides for selling on Amazon are 100% free.

Legal Concerns Surrounding Warranties and Material Differences

Retail arbitrage can become problematic when unauthorized sellers attempt to resell products with warranties or extended guarantees from their original manufacturers. Case law suggests that such items may be considered materially different than those advertised by authorized retailers, potentially leading to legal issues for the seller.

Understanding First Sale Doctrine Principles & Material Differences

The First Sale Doctrine is a legal precept that permits people to purchase and sell copyrighted items without obtaining consent from the copyright owner. However, this doctrine has its limitations when it comes to retail arbitrage.

If a product sold by an unauthorized party does not come with a warranty or guarantee offered by the manufacturer, then it could be deemed materially different under case law (see Omega S.A. v Costco Wholesale Corp.Tracfone Wireless, Inc. v. Pak China Grp. Co.Movado Grp., Inc. v. Matagorda Ventures, Inc.Perkins School for the Blind v. Maxi–Aids, Inc.Beltronics USA, Inc. v Midwest Inventory Distribution, LLC; I-Net Distributors, LLC; Audio Video Man; Kevin Burke; Steve WebbOsawa & Co. v. B & H PHOTO to name a few). 

The main takeaway from many of these cases is that, as a brand owner or company, you may not be interested in offering a warranty for your products if they’re distributed through unauthorized channels for various reasons. The biggest reason is that the distribution chain is unknown, and it’s unclear what kind of condition the product will be when it reaches the end customer. 

Not offering a warranty for products sold through unauthorized means makes the product materially different from when it was initially made and distributed and materially other than the offer made to the customer. It might seem silly from the outside, but because there’s a real possibility a consumer may opt not to purchase an item because it doesn’t have a warranty or that warranty is different than what the manufacturer offers, the difference is legally material and constitute another product.

That leads us to improper use of a trademark. One of the most common legal paths brands and companies can take is the illegal use of their trademark when selling these materially different goods. Because the product being sold is not what they’ve produced or offered, one can argue that using the brand’s trademark(s) is no longer valid.

How Case Law Affects Retail Arbitrage Practices

  • Avoid Misrepresentations: Be transparent about your status as an unauthorized seller and clearly state whether any warranties are included or excluded in your listings.
  • Familiarize Yourself with Brands’ Policies: Some companies have strict rules against third-party sellers offering their products on online marketplaces like Amazon; ensure you know these before listing their merchandise for sale.
  • Incorporate Risk Management Strategies: Diversify your inventory across various categories and brands so that potential legal issues with one product don’t jeopardize your entire retail arbitrage business.

Be aware of the legal implications of warranties and material differences when engaging in retail arbitrage, as ignorance can lead to costly mistakes. To avoid any intellectual property infringement on Amazon, resellers need to understand how IP rights play a role in their practices.

Avoiding Intellectual Property Infringement on Amazon

Amazon is strict about selling products with Intellectual Property (IP) belonging to someone else. To avoid infringing on IP rights and facing potential suspension, use tools like Greenlight before listing any new items for sale through your account. More on that below.

Amazon FBA sellers must be extra careful because a suspended account can mean thousands or tens of thousands of dollars of inventory stranded in Amazon warehouses if an account is suspended. There is no way to drop the low selling price and run a fire sale to eliminate inventory.

Importance of Respecting IP Rights in Retail Arbitrage

It is essential for those engaged in retail arbitrage to show consideration for the intellectual property of other businesses. Unauthorized sellers who list products with protected trademarks or copyrights risk getting their Amazon seller accounts suspended. Additionally, legal consequences may arise from such violations. Always ensure you have permission to sell a product or verify that it falls under the First Sale Doctrine before listing it online.

Using Seller Journal Greenlight Effectively

Greenlight is a free tool. We’ve put together a Seller Journal to track reports of brands filing intellectual property complaints and sending cease-and-desist letters to Amazon sellers. The database contains over 1,000 brands and is easily searchable anywhere on your computer or mobile device.

To search the database, you only need to head to the Greenlight page and search for a brand you’re curious about. No login is required.

Using tools like Greenlight ensures that your retail arbitrage business stays compliant with Amazon’s policies and avoids potential legal issues related to intellectual property infringement.

Respecting intellectual property rights is essential for a successful retail arbitrage business. Exploring alternative models and implementing effective strategies is vital to build on this foundation and achieve long-term success in e-commerce.

Seller Journal Greenlight

A database of over 1,000 seller-contributed brands at your fingertips. 100% Free.

Long-term Success in E-commerce Beyond Retail Arbitrage

Retail arbitrage has its merits as a side hustle or additional income stream, but let’s face it: it won’t make you the next Jeff Bezos. To achieve long-term success and potentially life-changing profits, consider exploring alternative e-commerce models that offer more control over your business.

Exploring Alternative E-Commerce Models

  • Dropshipping: A low-risk model where you partner with suppliers who fulfill orders on your behalf.
  • Private Labeling: Create and sell products under your own brand name for higher profit margins and branding opportunities.
  • Affiliate Marketing: Promote other companies’ products online and earn commissions from customer purchases through referral links.
  • Digital Products: Sell ebooks, courses, or software without worrying about inventory management or shipping costs.
Further Reading

Looking for a Retail Arbitrage alternative? Check out our guide on starting a dropshipping business–keep zero inventory and work entirely from your couch (probably).

Tips for Achieving Long-Term Success

  1. Invest time learning digital marketing skills like SEO, social media advertising, and email marketing campaigns to drive organic traffic toward your online store or listings. To get started, check out this comprehensive guide by Backlinko on Digital Marketing Strategies & Techniques That Work In [Current Year].
  2. Create a distinctive image that resonates with your intended demographic. This will help you stand out in the competitive online marketplaces.
  3. Focus on providing exceptional customer service to foster loyalty and encourage repeat purchases.
  4. Continuously analyze your sales data, customer feedback, and industry trends to optimize your product offerings and marketing strategies for maximum growth potential. To learn more about e-commerce analytics tools, read this article by BigCommerce: E-Commerce Analytics Tools & Metrics.

Frequently Asked Questions

Retail arbitrage is a business model where sellers purchase products from retail stores at a lower price and resell them for a profit. The legality of retail arbitrage is a common question among sellers. Here are some answers to frequently asked questions:

Is Retail Arbitrage Illegal?

Retail arbitrage is not illegal as long as sellers comply with applicable laws and platform policies. It is essential to respect intellectual property rights and ensure that you are an authorized seller when necessary to avoid legal issues or account suspensions.

Is Retail Arbitrage Allowed on Amazon?

Yes, retail arbitrage is allowed on Amazon, and Amazon retail arbitrage is an incredibly lucrative and sought-after side hustle. However, sellers must adhere to the platform’s rules and regulations, including providing accurate product information, abiding by category restrictions, maintaining good customer service standards, and respecting intellectual property rights.

Is Amazon eBay Arbitrage Legal?

Amazon-eBay arbitrage is legal as long as sellers follow both platforms’ policies regarding selling items purchased from one marketplace on another. It is essential to provide accurate product descriptions and images while complying with the shipping requirements of each site.

Can You Make a Living off Retail Arbitrage?

Some individuals can make a living off retail arbitrage. However, success depends on factors such as sourcing profitable products consistently and effectively managing time, inventory, and expenses. Retail arbitrage can be a viable side hustle or full-time business with proper planning and execution.


Retail arbitrage can be profitable for small business owners and online sellers. It is imperative to take heed of Amazon’s regulations, oversee operations shrewdly, and observe intellectual property rights when engaging in retail arbitrage. Private labeling can also be an alternative option for those looking to build their own brand on Amazon.

Disclaimer: We are not lawyers. While we strive to be as factual and accurate as possible, your situation may be unique. Please seek the advice of a legal professional.


We ensure our product and service reviews remain unbiased through a set of rules and guidelines we follow. We paid for many of the products we’ve reviewed. We may earn commission through affiliate links in these reviews, which helps fund our independent testing efforts. Learn more about our review guidelines and affiliate link policies. As an Amazon Associate, The Seller Journal earns from qualifying purchases. Special thanks to Depositphotos for being our exclusive provider of stock imagery.